The subject of taxes has been a controversial one since the beginning of civilization. I’m not someone who thinks taxes are completely unnecessary. They are. We could not run our government – either state or federal – without some kind of a tax system.
Our Founders believed that a strong central government needed to be sustained financially through taxes. In Article 1, Section 8 of our Constitution, they wrote:
The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defense and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and excises shall be uniform throughout the United States. [sic]
They continued on to enumerate the specific powers that the federal government was given under the Constitution. (NOTE: “general Welfare” [sic] as used in the Constitution did not mean welfare as it exists today. It meant the federal union as a whole as opposed to particular States or the special interests of select persons or groups.)
On the other hand, God instructs His people to give money to church or synagogue for specific purposes. The custom of paying “tithes and offerings” to the church goes back millennia. The first tithe the Bible records was that which Abraham paid to Melchizedek. A tithe represented 10% of a person’s income or property. In the Old Testament, a tithe was given to support the priests, as well as the stranger, the fatherless (orphans), and the widow (Deut. 26:12-13). The purpose of the tithe in the New Testament is not as clearly spelled out as in the Old Testament, but there is nothing to indicate that the purpose of the tithe had changed – except the New Testament seems to stress that giving should be voluntary and done cheerfully.
Taxes and Tithes – a synoptic chart
Comparing the way taxes and tithes are supposed to be spent struck me as very interesting.
|Article 1, Section 8 of our Constitution, enumerates the powers of our government, and thus the things our tax money should be spent on, as follows:
||By contrast, the church is supposed to spend our tithes and offerings on the following:
Taxes and Tithes Today
While the directive of the church hasn’t changed, it no longer needs to support the fatherless, the strangers and the widows. The government now does that through a myriad of social/welfare programs – and takes more than 10% of our money in taxes to support these programs. To be fair, much of our tax money is spent properly on running the government as prescribed in our Constitution. But nowhere in the powers listed for government in our Constitution is the government given the authority to support our orphans, widows or strangers.
Don’t misunderstand, providing a safety net for the disadvantaged is a good thing – but it should come from the church in the form of charity and not from the state in the form of entitlements.
Whether the church has willingly abdicated its responsibilities to those in need or the government has usurped the church’s responsibilities, is an argument worth having. As someone who has advocated for limited government, I continually come to realize that limited government is not possible unless We the People fill in the gaps. We have been content to let government take care of those in need but we are outraged that people have become dependent on government and develop an “entitlement” mentality.
It shouldn’t be any surprise that life doesn’t quite work out as well when biblical principles have been perverted. When government became the chief distributor of charity, relabeling it “entitlements”, personal accountability went out the window and the dole increased almost exponentially. That should be expected. After all, when charity existed only within the realm of the church, accountability was built into the system. If your neighbor was out of work through no fault of his own and needed help feeding his family, you knew if his need was legitimate. You also knew if he was a lazy good-for-nothing that lounged around all day and drank beer and watched television. Churches know who the truly needy are in their neighborhoods and they know how to minister to them in ways that go well beyond the physical. Government doesn’t know such things.
Consequently, government has grown as dependency on government has grown – ironically enslaving those they seem to be helping by replacing the Church’s work ethic with an entitlement mentality. Since we have allowed government to take care of things previously under the auspices of the Church, the government has felt free to start dictating morality as well – further replacing the Church. As our government has become more benevolent with our money, our hearts seem to become harder. Maybe we’re content to have government do what we’re supposed to be doing personally and through our churches.
Unfortunately, government is more than willing to do what we’re supposed to be doing personally and through our churches and the churches have been content to let it. As a result, accountability suffers, compassion is delegated by strangers, the standard of morality is now being set by government, and the church becomes more and more inconsequential – along with its message. After all, who needs the church when you have Uncle Sam?
- Christianity Today
- Constitution 101
- Creation Corner
- Entertainment Today
- First Amendment
- Foundation of our Nation
- Guest Columns
- Human Interest
- Ignite the Pulpit
- Let's Talk
- Money matters
- Racial Issues
- Tea Party
- Trump elevator pitch
- World news
Guest Columns5 days ago
Bradlee Dean Taking the Time to Confront Antifa to Their Face! (Video)
News4 days ago
Texas Governor Greg Abbott announces he is bussing migrants to New York City, sparking heavy criticism
Executive5 days ago
Jackie Walorski – new information
Legislative4 days ago
Liz Cheney for President?
Judicial2 days ago
Bodega clerk who defended himself from attacker will be moving back to Dominican Republic
Executive2 days ago
Inflation Reduction Act?
News17 hours ago
Albuquerque police arrest man allegedly responsible for murders of four Muslim men
Accountability5 days ago
Veterans sleep on Capitol steps after GOP blocks burn pit bill