A three-judge panel rejected New Jersey’s Obama eligibility challenge within twenty-four hours of hearing oral argument.
A quick decision
The decision by the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court was as terse as it was swift. It came down one day after the oral argument, and ran to only three pages. The substance of the decision ran like this:
We have carefully considered appellants’ arguments and conclude that these arguments are without merit. R. 2:11-3(e)(1)(E). We affirm substantially for the reasons set forth in ALJ Jeff S. Masin’s thorough and thoughtful written opinion of April 10, 2012, as adopted by the Secretary on April 12,2012.
The court cited this rule that lets the Appellate Division affirm a lower court without an opinion.
The court also cited this decision by Judge Masin. Masin handed this down on April 10, after a three-hour hearing.
Obama eligibility challenger reacts
Nick Purpura, the lead plaintiff/appellant in the case, reacted in outrage.
What do they mean, “ALJ Jeff S. Masin’s thorough and thoughtful written opinion”? What thought? There was no evidence! How could anyone rule that Barack Obama was born in Hawaii when there was never any evidence?
In the course of that hearing, Purpura’s lawyer, Mario Apuzzo, tried to call a witness to show that the White House PDF file, showing what looks like a birth certificate for Barack Obama, was a forgery. Judge Masin disallowed the witness after Alexandra Hill, arguing for Obama, conceded that she would not introduce the birth certificate into evidence. In fact, she never introduced any evidence to show Barack Obama’s identity or birthplace. Judge Masin, turning to Apuzzo, then said,
I’ve just won your case for you, if you prevail on the question of Obama’s obligation to prove his eligibility.
Masin meant by that, that the defense counsel would not introduce that White House PDF file or any other purported copy of the Obama birth certificate. Therefore, Apuzzo need not call his witness.
Nevertheless, Masin decided, hours later, to presume that Barack Obama was born in Hawaii and was therefore a natural born citizen. He also ruled that Obama, and his surrogates, need not show eligibility to nominate him in a primary.
Apuzzo carefully documented, in his brief, that Masin did not adequately follow New Jersey law. That law says that anyone running for office in a New Jersey election must qualify to hold that office. Barack Obama has not made any kind of showing. No Obama eligibility evidence is on file, even from the Election of 2008. Elections Division Director Robert Giles said that to Apuzzo and Purpura on the day they filed their challenge.
In a reply letter the day before the argument, Apuzzo attacked the respondents’ argument that the court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction, and that the New Jersey Secretary of State lacked discretion in ballot placement for Presidential elections. He also reiterated the heart of his Obama eligibility challenge: that Barack Obama is not a natural born citizen.
The Attorney General’s office had also said that Purpura and Moran had waited to long to act. At oral argument, Judge Clarkson Fisher hinted at that by saying that the Elections Division had already sent printed ballots to various county clerks. Apuzzo refused to concede that, but left it to the court to prescribe a remedy.
The appellate decision said nothing about anyone acting too late. But it ignored all of Apuzzo’s arguments, and said nothing to explain its decision beyond saying that Apuzzo’s argument was without merit. Purpura protested that the court violated his right of due process of law. He said that a court must say why an argument is without merit.
Apuzzo was not available for comment. Purpura vowed to appeal to the New Jersey Supreme Court.
- Judicial embarrassment
- Posse on warpath
- Arpaio wants proof
- Public appeal hearing
- Kenyan born Obama narrative
- Arpaio won’t quit
- Birth settled?
- Arpaio posse in Hawaii
- New Jersey appeal
- Kenya question
- $2 million
- Media pressure
- Natural-born citizen
- Obama eligibility: NJ ALJ makes new law
- Obama eligibility: NJ ALJ ducks issues
- Obama eligibility witnesses: Clinton campaign
- Obama eligibility challenge in New Jersey
- Obama: who is he?
- Obama birth certificate details
- Obama birth certificate petition
- Obama eligibility battle in Arizona legislature
- Obama birth certificate still suspect
- Obama born in Kenya?
- Presidential succession crisis
- Does anybody really know what time it is?
- Obama birth certificate investigation
- Obama birth certificate fraud analysis
- Obama birth certificate fraud
- Natural born citizen: what that means
- Obama eligibility: reactions to ruling
- Obama eligibility: flawed ruling
- Obama eligibility challenges multiply
- Obama eligibility challenges explode
- Obama eligibility challenges go forward
- Obama birth certificate does not satisfy
- Obama releases official-looking birth certificate
[amazon_carousel widget_type=”ASINList” width=”500″ height=”250″ title=”” market_place=”US” shuffle_products=”True” show_border=”False” asin=”B00375LOEG, 0451947673, 0800733940, 0062073303, 1595230734, 1936218003, 0981559662, 1935071874, 1932172378, 1936488299″ /]
Terry A. Hurlbut has been a student of politics, philosophy, and science for more than 35 years. He is a graduate of Yale College and has served as a physician-level laboratory administrator in a 250-bed community hospital. He also is a serious student of the Bible, is conversant in its two primary original languages, and has followed the creation-science movement closely since 1993.
- Christianity Today
- Constitution 101
- Creation Corner
- Entertainment Today
- First Amendment
- Foundation of our Nation
- Guest Columns
- Human Interest
- Ignite the Pulpit
- Let's Talk
- Money matters
- Racial Issues
- Tea Party
- Trump elevator pitch
- World news
Constitution3 days ago
Executive powers – a split decision
Accountability4 days ago
More companies covering travel costs for employees seeking an abortion
News3 days ago
Abortions can continue in Texas after Judge temporarily blocks pre-Roe ban
Accountability3 days ago
Military to continue providing abortions after Roe reversal
Constitution4 days ago
Executive powers and their limits
Legislative1 day ago
Rep. Lauren Boebert in worship service speech: ‘Church is supposed to direct government’
Accountability2 days ago
Supreme Court rules President Biden can end Trump’s ‘Remain in Mexico’ policy
Guest Columns9 hours ago
We must get Trump